logo

Your cart

Your cart is empty

homepage-image

Homemade Oreos

Prep

20m

Cook

6m

Total

26m

Ingredients

Method

Turn cooking mode on

Step 1

Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F.

Access all recipes now

chopping-block-knife-white

Cook along with all of our recipes

heart-white

Save your favourites and build your own collections

person-tick-white

Access all membership benefits

Already subscribed? Log in or switch accounts.

For

18

M

I

Cookie Dough:

1 3/4

cup

Freshly milled soft white wheat flour, finely milled

1/2

tsp

Baking powder

Access all recipes now

chopping-block-knife-white

Cook along with all of our recipes

heart-white

Save your favourites and build your own collections

person-tick-white

Access all membership benefits

Already subscribed? Log in or switch accounts.

Notes

You can use normal unsweetened cocoa powder, but it will not look like the traditional dark oreo.

Your private notes

Only visible to you

Next

Made it?

Comments

Cancel

P

Pei T

2 months ago

Hi is there a way to reduce sugar? The amount of sugar used in all cookie recipes is scary to me as I thought it is unhealthy for toddler to consume so much sugar? The wheat is healthy but I am not sure about the sugar

Like

Reply

Cancel

Kristin

a month ago

Yes you can reduce the sugar as much as you'd like. This is not a snack, it's a dessert

Like

Reply

Cancel

P

Pei T

a month ago

I sincerely asked for advice. I believe you do know that the amount of sugar will impact the texture and end result. I have tried reducing sugar in your peanut butter cookie recipe and it didn't work. Providing blanket statement of reducing sugar as much as I like is not helping me and I believe you do know the end product will end up in the trash. Thank you very much.

Like

Reply

Cancel

P

Pei T

a month ago

Since it is supposed to eat as dessert, it is not considered healthy/nutritious due to the sugar?

Like

Reply

Cancel

Kristin

a month ago

There are some recipes that I try to make the healthiest possible. Then there are others where we are trying to give someone a similar taste to the store bought options and it's not always the healthiest, BUT it's way healthier than the store-bought version. This would be one of those. If you don't like the ingredients, feel free to find a different recipe to try. There are literally hundreds to choose from here. :)

Like

Reply

Cancel

D

Danielle R

4 months ago

These are delicious!! Does everyone store them on the counter or the fridge? Thank you! Will definitely make again.

Like

Reply

Cancel

Kristin N

4 months ago

I’ve done both - either works :) glad you love them!

Like

Reply

Cancel

J

Joy S

4 months ago

So so good!! My husband and I absolutely love these and I am excited for my toddler to try them!! I love how they’re more of a soft cookie rather than the harder store-bought version. Perfect for movie night with milk and popcorn!!!

Like

Reply

Cancel

Kristin

4 months ago

So happy to hear!

Like

Reply

Cancel

D

Denise S

4 months ago

Was intimidated to try these. I used too big of a scoop, but I have to say they are delicious! Will definitely be making again but using a smaller cookie scoop!

Like

Reply

Cancel

Kristin

4 months ago

They look amazing!

Like

Reply

Cancel

Haylea S

5 months ago

I traded out the filling for peanut butter, and couldn’t find the black cocoa anywhere but Amazon so I used normals but they’re great!

Like

Reply

Cancel

Kristin

5 months ago

Looks great!

Like

Reply

Cancel

J

Jessica C

5 months ago

So good! Our crew devoured them. The directions were clear and I really appreciate that the measurements are in the method section.

Like

Reply

Cancel

Kristin

5 months ago

love it!

Like

Reply

Cancel

V

Vanessa B

5 months ago

Why does the recipe not print in metric when metric is selected. It appears all do this.

Like

Reply

Cancel

Kristin

5 months ago

I have reached out to the tech team for a fix for this. It's a known issue that we are working on :)

Like

Reply

Cancel

homepage-image

Homemade Oreos

Prep

20m

Cook

6m

Total

26m

Ingredients

Method

Turn cooking mode on

Step 1

Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F.

Access all recipes now

chopping-block-knife-white

Cook along with all of our recipes

heart-white

Save your favourites and build your own collections

person-tick-white

Access all membership benefits

Already subscribed? Log in or switch accounts.

For

18

M

I

Cookie Dough:

1 3/4

cup

Freshly milled soft white wheat flour, finely milled

1/2

tsp

Baking powder

Access all recipes now

chopping-block-knife-white

Cook along with all of our recipes

heart-white

Save your favourites and build your own collections

person-tick-white

Access all membership benefits

Already subscribed? Log in or switch accounts.

Notes

You can use normal unsweetened cocoa powder, but it will not look like the traditional dark oreo.

Your private notes

Only visible to you

Next

Made it?

Comments

Cancel

P

Pei T

2 months ago

Hi is there a way to reduce sugar? The amount of sugar used in all cookie recipes is scary to me as I thought it is unhealthy for toddler to consume so much sugar? The wheat is healthy but I am not sure about the sugar

Like

Reply

Cancel

Kristin

a month ago

Yes you can reduce the sugar as much as you'd like. This is not a snack, it's a dessert

Like

Reply

Cancel

P

Pei T

a month ago

I sincerely asked for advice. I believe you do know that the amount of sugar will impact the texture and end result. I have tried reducing sugar in your peanut butter cookie recipe and it didn't work. Providing blanket statement of reducing sugar as much as I like is not helping me and I believe you do know the end product will end up in the trash. Thank you very much.

Like

Reply

Cancel

P

Pei T

a month ago

Since it is supposed to eat as dessert, it is not considered healthy/nutritious due to the sugar?

Like

Reply

Cancel

Kristin

a month ago

There are some recipes that I try to make the healthiest possible. Then there are others where we are trying to give someone a similar taste to the store bought options and it's not always the healthiest, BUT it's way healthier than the store-bought version. This would be one of those. If you don't like the ingredients, feel free to find a different recipe to try. There are literally hundreds to choose from here. :)

Like

Reply

Cancel

D

Danielle R

4 months ago

These are delicious!! Does everyone store them on the counter or the fridge? Thank you! Will definitely make again.

Like

Reply

Cancel

Kristin N

4 months ago

I’ve done both - either works :) glad you love them!

Like

Reply

Cancel

J

Joy S

4 months ago

So so good!! My husband and I absolutely love these and I am excited for my toddler to try them!! I love how they’re more of a soft cookie rather than the harder store-bought version. Perfect for movie night with milk and popcorn!!!

Like

Reply

Cancel

Kristin

4 months ago

So happy to hear!

Like

Reply

Cancel

D

Denise S

4 months ago

Was intimidated to try these. I used too big of a scoop, but I have to say they are delicious! Will definitely be making again but using a smaller cookie scoop!

Like

Reply

Cancel

Kristin

4 months ago

They look amazing!

Like

Reply

Cancel

Haylea S

5 months ago

I traded out the filling for peanut butter, and couldn’t find the black cocoa anywhere but Amazon so I used normals but they’re great!

Like

Reply

Cancel

Kristin

5 months ago

Looks great!

Like

Reply

Cancel

J

Jessica C

5 months ago

So good! Our crew devoured them. The directions were clear and I really appreciate that the measurements are in the method section.

Like

Reply

Cancel

Kristin

5 months ago

love it!

Like

Reply

Cancel

V

Vanessa B

5 months ago

Why does the recipe not print in metric when metric is selected. It appears all do this.

Like

Reply

Cancel

Kristin

5 months ago

I have reached out to the tech team for a fix for this. It's a known issue that we are working on :)

Like

Reply

Cancel