logo

Your cart

Your cart is empty

homepage-image

Peanut Butter Cookies

Prep

5m

Cook

10m

Total

15m

Ingredients

Method

Turn cooking mode on

Step 1

Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F. and line a baking sheet with parchment paper.

Access all recipes now

chopping-block-knife-white

Cook along with all of our recipes

heart-white

Save your favourites and build your own collections

person-tick-white

Access all membership benefits

Already subscribed? Log in or switch accounts.

For

24

M

I

1/2

cup

Butter, softened

1/3

cup

Brown sugar

1/3

cup

Sugar

Access all recipes now

chopping-block-knife-white

Cook along with all of our recipes

heart-white

Save your favourites and build your own collections

person-tick-white

Access all membership benefits

Already subscribed? Log in or switch accounts.

Your private notes

Only visible to you

Next

Made it?

Comments

Cancel

M

Molly S

4 days ago

Do you think you could replace any of the sugar with honey? And what adjustments would you then make? Just curious, about to make these and so excited!

Like

Reply

Cancel

Kristin

4 days ago

I'm not too sure about that as I haven't tried it

Like

Reply

Cancel

Katherine P

a month ago

These turned out pretty good. Not too sweet, but mine tasted a little bland so I served them with a smear of strawberry jam and they were delicious! (Mine did turn out a crumbly and fell apart before they were cooled. Is this normal?)

Like

Reply

Cancel

Kristin

a month ago

Crumbly is not normal, could it be that your flour wasn't milled fine enough?

Like

Reply

Cancel

Katherine P

a month ago

Thank you for responding! I usually mill on the finest setting. It’s possible the knob got moved a little bit but nothing that I would think would be very noticeable. I use the wonder mill classic. Maybe it doesn’t grind as fine as a stone mill… made them yesterday and they’re all gone now, so I guess that’s all that matters,😄 but just wondered if I did something wrong.

Like

Reply

Cancel

Kristin

a month ago

The wondermill does a great job of milling fine flour. so just make sure it's on the finest setting next time

Like

Reply

Cancel

Amy C

4 months ago

Great recipe! We all loved them!

Like

Reply

Cancel

Kristin

4 months ago

Love hearing this!

Like

Reply

Cancel

S

Sonia E

5 months ago

Do you need to use unsalted butter or can you use salted?

Like

Reply

Cancel

Kristin

5 months ago

I use salted in all my recipes

Like

Reply

Cancel

M

Melissa

5 months ago

Do you chill these or allow time for flour bran to moisten

Like

Reply

Cancel

Kristin

5 months ago

We do not do either of those things for this recipe and they turn great - but feel free if you prefer!

Like

Reply

Cancel

homepage-image

Peanut Butter Cookies

Prep

5m

Cook

10m

Total

15m

Ingredients

Method

Turn cooking mode on

Step 1

Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F. and line a baking sheet with parchment paper.

Access all recipes now

chopping-block-knife-white

Cook along with all of our recipes

heart-white

Save your favourites and build your own collections

person-tick-white

Access all membership benefits

Already subscribed? Log in or switch accounts.

For

24

M

I

1/2

cup

Butter, softened

1/3

cup

Brown sugar

1/3

cup

Sugar

Access all recipes now

chopping-block-knife-white

Cook along with all of our recipes

heart-white

Save your favourites and build your own collections

person-tick-white

Access all membership benefits

Already subscribed? Log in or switch accounts.

Your private notes

Only visible to you

Next

Made it?

Comments

Cancel

M

Molly S

4 days ago

Do you think you could replace any of the sugar with honey? And what adjustments would you then make? Just curious, about to make these and so excited!

Like

Reply

Cancel

Kristin

4 days ago

I'm not too sure about that as I haven't tried it

Like

Reply

Cancel

Katherine P

a month ago

These turned out pretty good. Not too sweet, but mine tasted a little bland so I served them with a smear of strawberry jam and they were delicious! (Mine did turn out a crumbly and fell apart before they were cooled. Is this normal?)

Like

Reply

Cancel

Kristin

a month ago

Crumbly is not normal, could it be that your flour wasn't milled fine enough?

Like

Reply

Cancel

Katherine P

a month ago

Thank you for responding! I usually mill on the finest setting. It’s possible the knob got moved a little bit but nothing that I would think would be very noticeable. I use the wonder mill classic. Maybe it doesn’t grind as fine as a stone mill… made them yesterday and they’re all gone now, so I guess that’s all that matters,😄 but just wondered if I did something wrong.

Like

Reply

Cancel

Kristin

a month ago

The wondermill does a great job of milling fine flour. so just make sure it's on the finest setting next time

Like

Reply

Cancel

Amy C

4 months ago

Great recipe! We all loved them!

Like

Reply

Cancel

Kristin

4 months ago

Love hearing this!

Like

Reply

Cancel

S

Sonia E

5 months ago

Do you need to use unsalted butter or can you use salted?

Like

Reply

Cancel

Kristin

5 months ago

I use salted in all my recipes

Like

Reply

Cancel

M

Melissa

5 months ago

Do you chill these or allow time for flour bran to moisten

Like

Reply

Cancel

Kristin

5 months ago

We do not do either of those things for this recipe and they turn great - but feel free if you prefer!

Like

Reply

Cancel